MLB Jersey i purchased was a cheaply made knock off. It was a light, shiny flimsy polyester (as opposed to a double knit that they had promised). Its like the shirt is silk screened. The picture t... See more
Company replied
While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more
To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more
See what reviewers are saying
I was apprehensive about ordering from them due to reviews on multiple sites but glad i did. Ordered a charlie hough dodgers jersey. Came within the extended delivery window due to covid. Quality jers... See more
Quality merchandise. Would suggest the "it will take MANY weeks to fulfill any order" be more prominently displayed. Didn't notice that until some time after order placement. Expectation of Some... See more
i ordered two custom throwbacks of my two favorite Oakland Raiders from when I was an 11year-old; Ken stabler and Marv Hubbard. In 1970, the Raiders wore road whites that featured silver numbers. I or... See more
3.7
Average
134 reviews
Replied to 100% of negative reviews
Typically replies within 24 hours
How this company uses Trustpilot
See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.
MLB Jersey is CRAP!!!!
MLB Jersey i purchased was a cheaply made knock off. It was a light, shiny flimsy polyester (as opposed to a double knit that they had promised). Its like the shirt is silk screened.
The picture they have on their website has pinstripes both on the inside & outside of the jersey. The jersey i received is white on the inside. Quality is cheap as shit! Not worth $227.00
DO NOT BUY from this company! They are a ripoff and you cannot get i touch with anyone.
They have a 3.7 rating as well!!! This should tell you something!!
14 October 2025
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
This buyer is a total IDIOT...the jersey comes directly from Majestic and the Pinstripes are Sublimated which is EXACTLY the way Pinstripes have been produced on baseball jerseys for the past 20 years including today.
The overall quality of the jersey is excellent as is every single jersey we have sold over the past 25 years.
Package Never Received!
After initially requesting a refund this was the response I received from Customthrowbackjerseys: C
Custom Throwback Jerseys
January 4, 2025, 1:32:15 PM PST
Jersey will ship out in the time frame CLEARLY indicated that you did not read. This will be my last response...so GET LOST
As of today Friday January 17, 2025 I have not received my package that I paid $200 for because this company sent to an address with the wrong Zip code. I have contacted Customthrowbackjerseys regarding this matter, but I have not received any response. I had to reach out to USPS who confirmed that this package was shipped to a different address. NOW I WILL take whatever necessary measures and seek the powers that be to clear this matter up. AGAIN from the beginning it was an awful experience, but now that Customthrowbackjerseys has received my payment on December 17, 2024 and forced me to wait until now to receive this package, only to find out that my $200. package was delivered to the wrong address!!!
"upated 1.18.2025 YES it's your fault because you sent the package with the WRONG ZIP CODE. see the tracking... it clearly shows that it went to an address with ZIP CODE 91737.... MY ZIP CODE IS 91739, WHICH is clearly stated via PAYPAL. Now go and check this TRACKING: LA533412569CA... ?? ANYONE looking at this review, can see that this tracking is for an address with ZIP CODE 91737
16 January 2025
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
Jersey was shipped to the exact address the buyer provided. I am not quite sure how it is our fault that USPS delivered the package to the wrong address ??
Somewhat slow turnaround, but a quality product
Although the time from ordering my nordiques Goulet Jersey was a bit long, I would definitely order again. The quality is good and appearance is accurate for the time when he played. Would have been 5 stars if it had arrived quicker. (Set April ‘24 but it was actually April ‘22)
27 April 2024
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
Thanks for your kind words and I am glad you enjoy the jersey.
I must WARN buyers that there are now several SCAM websites that have stolen & copied all our products, pictures, and descriptions as well as our name. The SCAM websites are called "https://dothrowbackjersey.shop/" & "https://customvintagejersey.com/).
They are selling fake counterfeit crap jerseys from China which resemble nothing like the pictures they have stolen from us. Our legitimate website is "customthrowbackjerseys.com" which is where you will get the finest quality 100% licensed throwback jerseys anywhere online.
Best simple advise I can give buyers to avoid getting scammed is NEVER purchase anything from a website that does not provide you with a telephone number to call them.
This Place is Amazing
This Place is Amazing. Got Two Charles Barkley Throwbacks and Michael Jordan White Sox Jersey. Best Quality, Best Service and to be honest the best secret weapn in the Jersey Collection Game. If you are not making some purchases here you are missing out on standing out from the crowd. CTJ for the WIN!!! Get with the program and empty your wallet here!!
4 August 2024
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
Thanks for your kind words and I am glad you enjoy the jerseys.
I must WARN buyers that there are now several SCAM websites that have stolen & copied all our products, pictures, and descriptions as well as our name. The SCAM websites are called "https://dothrowbackjersey.shop/" & "https://customvintagejersey.com/).
They are selling fake counterfeit crap jerseys from China which resemble nothing like the pictures they have stolen from us. Our legitimate website is "customthrowbackjerseys.com" which is where you will get the finest quality 100% licensed throwback jerseys anywhere online.
Best simple advise I can give buyers to avoid getting scammed is NEVER purchase anything from a website that does not provide you with a telephone number to call them.
This Customer Service....
I contacted this company to verify that their products were legit and I have attached their response. Unbelievable. I can't attach a photo, so below is the correspondence:
"Hello,
Are these genuine majestic jerseys? Or just suppose to look like one?
Thanks"
Their response:
Mon, Jul 8 at 5:27 PM
If you need to ask that question you need to buy elsewhere...
8 July 2024
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
This person has NEVER purchased anything from us, and the first email we received from her was rude and insulting...
Custom Throwback Jerseys
I have purchased two (2) jerseys from customthrowbackjerseys.com - one was a Kansas City Royals baseball jersey and the other was a Minnesota Vikings jersey from 1969 (which had the commemorative NFL patch on the shoulder). Simply stated, both jerseys came out perfectly. Plus, the quality of the jerseys is unmatched by other custom jersey manufacturers. I will be buying jerseys from them again.
20 December 2023
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
Thanks for your kind words and I am glad you enjoy the jerseys.
I must WARN buyers that there is a SCAM website that has stolen & copied all our products, pictures, and descriptions as well as our name. The SCAM website is called "customvintagejersey.com"). They are selling fake counterfeit crap jerseys from China which resemble nothing like the pictures they have stolen from us. Our legitimate website is "customthrowbackjerseys.com" which is where you will get the finest quality 100% licensed throwback jerseys anywhere online.
I waited 52 years…
I waited 52 years to buy my Gassoff sweater.
I could not possibly be happier. It came faster than expected, beautifully stitched, quality material and it already feels like home.
5 April 2024
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
Thanks for your kind words and I am glad you enjoy the jersey.
I must WARN buyers that there is a SCAM website that has stolen & copied all our products, pictures, and descriptions as well as our name. The SCAM website is called "customvintagejersey.com"). They are selling fake counterfeit crap jerseys from China which resemble nothing like the pictures they have stolen from us. Our legitimate website is "customthrowbackjerseys.com" which is where you will get the finest quality 100% licensed throwback jerseys anywhere online.
Love my jersey
My jersey is perfect. It is such high quality and is exactly what I wanted! You will not go wrong with ordering from them.
29 March 2024
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
Thanks for your kind words and I am glad you enjoy the jersey.
I must WARN buyers that there is a SCAM website that has stolen & copied all our products, pictures, descriptions as well as our name. The SCAM website is called "customvintagejersey.com"). They are selling fake counterfeit crap jerseys from China which resemble nothing like the pictures they have stolen from us. Our legitimate website is "customthrowbackjerseys.com" which is where you will get the finest quality 100% licensed throwback jerseys anywhere online.
Best simple advise I can give buyers to avoid getting scammed is NEVER purchase anything from a website that does not provide you with a telephone number to call them.
Awesome jersey!!
20 March 2024
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
Thanks for your kind words and I am glad you enjoy the jersey.
I must WARN buyers that there is a SCAM website that has stolen & copied all our products, pictures, and descriptions as well as our name. The SCAM website is called "customvintagejersey.com"). They are selling fake counterfeit crap jerseys from China which resemble nothing like the pictures they have stolen from us. Our legitimate website is "customthrowbackjerseys.com" which is where you will get the finest quality 100% licensed throwback jerseys anywhere online.
Best simple advise I can give buyers to avoid getting scammed is NEVER purchase anything from a website that does not provide you with a telephone number to call them.
Top notch quality
Top notch quality, couldn't be happier with the jersey!
9 March 2024
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
Thanks for your kind words and I am glad you enjoy the jersey.
I must WARN buyers that there is a SCAM website that has stolen & copied all our products, pictures, and descriptions as well as our name. The SCAM website is called "customvintagejersey.com"). They are selling fake counterfeit crap jerseys from China which resemble nothing like the pictures they have stolen from us. Our legitimate website is "customthrowbackjerseys.com" which is where you will get the finest quality 100% licensed throwback jerseys anywhere online.
Fantastic product.
28 February 2024
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
Thanks for your kind words and I am glad you enjoy the jersey.
I must WARN buyers that there is a SCAM website that has stolen & copied all our products, pictures, and descriptions as well as our name. The SCAM website is called "customvintagejersey.com"). They are selling fake counterfeit crap jerseys from China which resemble nothing like the pictures they have stolen from us. Our legitimate website is "customthrowbackjerseys.com" which is where you will get the finest quality 100% licensed throwback jerseys anywhere online.
Custom Pittsburgh Penguins jersey for Christmas
I couldn't have been more pleased with the jersey I had custom ordered with CTJ. It was a throwback jersey with a more obscure player and it was a Christmas gift for my oldest daughter who is a big Penguins fan. I ordered special patches to make her jersey extra nice and CTJ was great to work with in receiving those patches and sewing them on when customizing her jersey. I will definitely do business with this company again and I would highly recommend them to anyone I know.
19 December 2023
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
Thanks for your kind words and I am glad you enjoy the jersey.
I must WARN buyers that there is a SCAM website that has stolen & copied all our products, pictures, and descriptions as well as our name. The SCAM website is called "customvintagejersey.com"). They are selling fake counterfeit crap jerseys from China which resemble nothing like the pictures they have stolen from us. Our legitimate website is "customthrowbackjerseys.com" which is where you will get the finest quality 100% licensed throwback jerseys anywhere online.
Ordered a custom Quebec Nordiques…
Ordered a custom Quebec Nordiques jersey.
The jersey is awesome and looks professional.
Great job guys!!!
20 November 2023
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
Thanks for your kind words and I am glad you enjoy the jersey.
I must WARN buyers that there is a SCAM website that has stolen & copied all our products, pictures, and descriptions as well as our name. The SCAM website is called "customvintagejersey.com"). They are selling fake counterfeit crap jerseys from China which resemble nothing like the pictures they have stolen from us. Our legitimate website is "customthrowbackjerseys.com" which is where you will get the finest quality 100% licensed throwback jerseys anywhere online.
Outstanding jersey
Outstanding jersey, great detail, excellent communication- will definitely do business with Custom-throwback jerseys again.
Tom C
18 December 2023
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
Thanks for your kind words and I am glad you enjoy the jersey.
I must WARN buyers that there is a SCAM website that has stolen & copied all our products, pictures, and descriptions as well as our name. The SCAM website is called "customvintagejersey.com"). They are selling fake counterfeit crap jerseys from China which resemble nothing like the pictures they have stolen from us. Our legitimate website is "customthrowbackjerseys.com" which is where you will get the finest quality 100% licensed throwback jerseys anywhere online.
The jersey is great looks great and…
The jersey is great looks great and made to perfection. It was a great purchase and experience. I hope more people will get this message. Thank you.
5 January 2024
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
Thanks for your kind words and I am glad you enjoy the jersey.
I must WARN buyers that there is a SCAM website that has stolen & copied all our products, pictures, and descriptions as well as our name. The SCAM website is called "customvintagejersey.com"). They are selling fake counterfeit crap jerseys from China which resemble nothing like the pictures they have stolen from us. Our legitimate website is "customthrowbackjerseys.com" which is where you will get the finest quality 100% licensed throwback jerseys anywhere online.
OAKLAND RAIDERS JERSEY
Ordered an NFL Football 1970 FRED BILETNIKOFF Throwback Oakland Raiders Away Jersey. Arrived earlier than expected and was better than I expected. Fit was perfect and quality was EXCELLENT! I will definitely order from CUSTOMTHROWBACKJERSEYS.COM again.
10 October 2023
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
Thanks for your kind words and I am glad you enjoy the jersey.
I must WARN buyers that there is a SCAM website that has stolen & copied all our products, pictures, and descriptions as well as our name. The SCAM website is called "customvintagejersey.com"). They are selling fake counterfeit crap jerseys from China which resemble nothing like the pictures they have stolen from us. Our legitimate website is "customthrowbackjerseys.com" which is where you will get the finest quality 100% licensed throwback jerseys anywhere online.
Excellent service and amazing quality…
Excellent service and amazing quality of the jersey provided. Really happy and will buy more in future! Thanks!
2 December 2023
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
Thanks for your kind words and I am glad you enjoy the jersey.
I must WARN buyers that there is a SCAM website that has stolen & copied all our products, pictures, and descriptions as well as our name. The SCAM website is called "customvintagejersey.com"). They are selling fake counterfeit crap jerseys from China which resemble nothing like the pictures they have stolen from us. Our legitimate website is "customthrowbackjerseys.com" which is where you will get the finest quality 100% licensed throwback jerseys anywhere online.
great, high quality product and good customer service
Great, high quality jersey and made the perfect gift! I really liked how well they communicated the order status throughout and I was very satisfied with everything from purchasing to shipping time. Highly recommend and great company.
11 September 2023
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
Thanks for your kind words and I am glad you enjoy the jersey.
I must WARN buyers that there is a SCAM website that has stolen & copied all our products, pictures, and descriptions as well as our name. The SCAM website is called "customvintagejersey.com"). They are selling fake counterfeit crap jerseys from China which resemble nothing like the pictures they have stolen from us. Our legitimate website is "customthrowbackjerseys.com" which is where you will get the finest quality 100% licensed throwback jerseys anywhere online.
Excellent quality
Excellent quality. Would order again without hesitation.
22 September 2023
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
Thanks for your kind words and I am glad you enjoy the jersey.
I must WARN buyers that there is a SCAM website that has stolen & copied all our products, pictures, and descriptions as well as our name. The SCAM website is called "customvintagejersey.com"). They are selling fake counterfeit crap jerseys from China which resemble nothing like the pictures they have stolen from us. Our legitimate website is "customthrowbackjerseys.com" which is where you will get the finest quality 100% licensed throwback jerseys anywhere online.
I definitely recommend!
The jersey is a high quality product, and definitely met expectations. Estimated production time was accurate. I would definitely recommend to others.
17 October 2023
Unprompted review
Reply from Customthrowbackjerseys
Thanks for your kind words and I am glad you enjoy the jersey.
I must WARN buyers that there is a SCAM website that has stolen & copied all our products, pictures, and descriptions as well as our name. The SCAM website is called "customvintagejersey.com"). They are selling fake counterfeit crap jerseys from China which resemble nothing like the pictures they have stolen from us. Our legitimate website is "customthrowbackjerseys.com" which is where you will get the finest quality 100% licensed throwback jerseys anywhere online.
The Trustpilot Experience
Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.
Companies can ask for reviews via automatic invitations. Labeled Verified, they’re about genuine experiences.
Learn more about other kinds of reviews.
We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.
Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.
Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.
Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.
Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.