Coinfully Reviews 

Very easy to work with. They kept in contact with me throughout and were quick to respond whenever I contacted them.
The payment i received came the same day they received my coins.
I highly recommend their services.

I was so nervous having never done this before and they made it so easy... Take pictures, send in, they quote, pay for shipping and insurance and then direct deposit payment into account. I would highly recommend them to anyone.
I was not in my right mind after losing my father unexpectedly, dealing with probate and just being traumatized. They were SO great to work with.

I was able to get an appraisal for my coin and ship it to Coinfully with step by step instructions. I was paid as soon as they received my coin and even reimbursed for the shipping charges!

Dealing with Matt was a pleasant experience. He did everything he said and paid promptly as promised. I will be using him again in the future.

Man, I will tell you what! These guys are the real deal. No BS. The transaction was quick, the appraisal was better than any local coin or pawn shop. They were extremely fast in response to my emails. I shipped my goodies off and had a check in my hands in less than 5 days including ship time. I fully trust and would do business with them again.

Our family had a vast coin collection that our Dad started 40 years ago. When he passed away, it sat in a few large crates waiting for someone to do something with it. I contacted Coinfully and got help right away with easy-to-follow instructions and very, very patient people on the other end of the phone. Happily, the collection was valuable and even with some last-minute changes to the inventory, we were completely satisfied and recommend Coinfully to others in the same situation. Thanks for your care and concern, Steve D Massachusetts

Great Business these Brothers have Created…
Wow too much to list..
I was unaware and looking for the best possible way to get the most out of a Doomsday collection of Gold & Silver that my Dad was gathering before I was born, and was never to be touched…
Came across COINFULLY ( search engine how to get best price for you coin collection) and answered a few questions and added a few pictures..
Within less than 24 hours I had some communication with Travis first he lead me to the next step and then Wyatt had a conversation put on a schedule to go over what they had found…
Again not to discount my intelligence or knowledge, I myself l know my limits and realistically knew I couldn’t become an expert over night…
So the first preliminary appraisal was nothing to pass off as not competitive, in fact it was either top dollar if not more money that others were giving ( obviously EBay prices everyone would be Millionaires) nevertheless after my initial phone conversation I spoke with my wife and she agreed let’s have COINFULLY come from North Carolina to Chicago and go through our stash…
I never would believe they could of done it with one person but Matt, Wyatt’s right hand appraiser for many years of mentoring came to our house, 10am on the dot as scheduled and went right to work..
Let me cut to the chase, we gave them everything that they appraised…
Although I seen some things that I may had thought had a bit more value ( in my uneducated mind and internet surfing) Matt explained their ( COINFULLY’s ) position and it made sense….
Once again I didn’t have to sell..
I could keep sell or give portions of what I had…
Never was there any feeling that I was getting rushed or hit with an ultimatum…
It was business as usual for a family owned company with many ties to the Coin and the Numismatic Prestigious Auction houses, one of which the Mother of the brothers had played a important role at Stacks & Bowers of New York..
Nevertheless Honesty is the best policy and as we graded my collection Matt used the GraySheet right in front of me and shown me where his calculations derived from…
And all and all a emotional rollercoaster for me to sell something not to be touched but incase of war or catastrophic collapse of the dollar, they set my mind at ease and the wire was made and orchestrated without a hitch at 4pm central time 5pm out east…
Within an hour the money was in my account..
Remember HONESTY….
Wyatt called me a week later after getting my paperwork formally in order and to my surprise he said I have some bad news and good news..
The bad is Matt forgot to figure in a bag of uncirculated dimes ( they were in his list ) but only counted one in his cash out tally) Wyatt then said the good news that after their 10% fee they were going to wire my account another $22,300.00….
I was floored and unbelievably taken back by their incredible amount of Self discipline and Honesty these Brothers hold and give to Keep their Personal & Business reputation too an outstanding level unheard of I would say in this type of long distance business relationship…
Hats off to Wyatt, Travis , and Matt for unwavering dedication to the golden rule …. (HONESTY)
Treat people the way you want to be treated with the upmost Honesty, Respect and attention to detail..
Thank You
COINFULLY Family
Cordially
Dan J

Coinfully made it easy to sell my coins. I followed their online instructions for receiving a free appraisal. They responded immediately to my inquiry with their appraisal and a competitive offer. When I accepted the offer they immediately provided easy to follow instructions for sending my coins to them. Within 2 days of sending my coins I received a check. They did everything they said they would do and made the whole process far easier than I imagined it would be. Every step of the way the customer service was very friendly and responsive. I couldn't be happier.

Very efficient and precise instructions Made the process very easy.

Extremely easy to use with good communications. They went faster than I anticipated, which was good. Just a couple of messages back and forth, including photos of my stuff, and there is was.

Coinfully makes selling you coins easy at a fair price. You take a picture, send it to them. You get an appraisal the same day. Send it to them- get paid the day it is received at their office. They gave me a better offer than my local store. We sold them 3 different batches of coins- each time the same experience. I would whole heartedly recommend them for anyone to use.

Swift, trustworthy. Highly recommend.

It went as advertised. Will use again

The folks at Coinfully have a very easy procedure for assessing a coin collection with a free appraisal. The appraisals I received were fair and honest. This took the stress off of my wife and I as we were navigating through the process. They are registered through the ANA as numismatic coin specialists. Everything is done online in the comfort of your home, send the coins, as soon as they receive them you get a wire transfer on the same day. Being Numismatics you can rely on Coinfully to give you a fair straightforward experience. They are always there for you to answer any questions you might have, thanks Coinfully!

Working with Coinfully was a great experience. To say I was hesitant to ship over $2K in coins would be an understatement, but it was beyond easy. By the time I received replies from local dealers, I already had payment from Coinfully. Matthew at Coinfully was extremely helpful and walked with through the process. I rarely write a review, but their service deserved one. I would highly recommend them.

Braden was very patient with me during the appraisal phase and Braden and Matthew were very helpful when I was ready to sell. Thanks for a very smooth process.

My first impression of Coinfully was not the best, and then Wyatt called. Wyatt and Travis are the founding partners at Coinfully and they are Amazing! Wyatt took the time to make sure I was comfortable with Coinfully's business model, and as a new comer to Numismatics he walked me through the process of find the best value, taking the right pictures, how to safely store the coins I choose to collect, etc. What a gift as I know next to nothing about the collection we inherited. Well I know a lot more today and am certain any future sales will go to Coinfully.
Sherri Mendenhall
Updated review

Everyone (I interacted with Braden and Trip) made the process as "stress free" as possible. It can be a little scary selling coins on-line, but they made is a very pleasant experience. It helps if you have an inventory of your coins that you can send (pictures help too) and you should have a good, realistic, idea of what you think the collection is worth. They gave us a very fair - and honest - appraisal of the collection that was on the higher side of what we expected. Once we agreed, they made the shipping easy too. Payment was also very fast. Personally, I would recommend Coinfully over going to your local coin dealer or attempting to sell your collection on ebay. It was low stress and easy to sell the collection in one transaction.

Coinfully helped me feel confident that my coins and payment would be handled in a timely manner. I never had any red flags or issues with my transactions. Braden F. helped me throughout my process with Coinfully. He was knowledgeable, trustworthy, and worked in a timely manner. I look forward to work with him again in the future. I recommend anyone that has a coin collection to consider Coinfully.

I have had the silver coins in my safe for about 50 some years and even though they were maturing financially. They were just sitting there. I Contacted Coinfully and they were great to deal with. I sent my coins in and was immediately appraised of their value with a check coming close behind. I went out in Purchased some shares of stock and before I knew it I was about $1200 in the hole. Since that time the stock has been going up nicely and within a couple of weeks I should be on my way to being a millionaire ha ha. Thank you Coinfully.